Straight Time Straight Time

Twitch-O-Meter: When Oscar Goes Bad.

Posted by Todd Brown at 11:00am.

Posted in Twitch-O-Meter .

An honor reserved for the best actors of their day or a destroyer of souls?  The little Golden man given out every year seems to have the uncanny ability to cloud the minds of its owners, leading them to make some simply hideous films in the aftermath of a win.  Yes, boys and girls, we have here a Twitch-o-Meter devoted to good actors gone bad.  We’ll leave the ladies for another day.

Robin Williams gets an honorable mention here as the poster boy for the Oscar-killing-a-career phenomenon simply for the sheer volume of lousy work he has cranked out since winning for Good Will Hunting in 1997.  The IMDB lists twenty seven credits for Williams since then, of which only three are what I’d consider particularly watchable and two of those are animated with Williams simply providing a voice.  Williams’ post-GWH body of work is remarkable for how consistently crappy it has been and yet none of it reaches quite the level of spectacular awfulness required to grant him entry to the top five examples of the Oscar curse in action.  Ready?  Here we go!

Jeremy Irons
Mr. Irons, come on down!  Jeremy Irons won in 1990 for Reversal of Fortune.  The man has an impressive body of work to his name both before and since, with even his commercial pay check roles generally being memorable, as was the case with his part in Die Hard: With A Vengeance.  And yet ... there he is in Dungeons and Dragons, the 2000 adaptation of the classic role playing game that stands, quite simply, as one of the worst films ever made.  It’s unbearable stuff and Irons himself is truly horrible in it.  Jeremy, Jeremy, Jeremy, what were you thinking?

Ben Kingsley
One of these things is not like the others:  GandhiBugsySchindler’s ListSexy BeastBloodRayne.  At least Sir Ben’s honest about what’s going on when he goes slumming.  The man had a pool to pay for, don’t you know?

Nicolas Cage
Nicolas Cage has always had a sort of Jekyll and Hyde thing going on, the man basically being either spectacularly good or absolutely, truly wretched throughout his entire career.  Thing is before winning the Oscar in ‘95 for Leaving Las Vegas he tended to make more interesting choices, seeking out the quirky independents where he generally shines, whereas post-Oscar he’s obviously started viewing himself as a movie star and tended to follow the big pay days, leading to more poor role choices and more bad Nic than good.  Cage is astonishingly bad in Kiss of Death - which I paid full theater price to pay - but that also released in ‘95, which means he hadn’t won anything yet and therefore it doesn’t qualify for this list.  Of the stuff that does qualify I’ll cast my vote for The Wicker Man though all signs are the remake of Bangkok Dangerous will be cleaning up come Razzie-time.  Maybe he should just stay away from the remakes ...

Jon Voight
Angelina’s daddy’s made a LOT of films since winning the Oscar for ‘78’s Coming Home and most of them are really quite good but, as is the case with Irons, when he makes a bad one it’s spectacularly bad, though usually entertainingly so.  Anaconda‘s the winner here, though it certainly falls into the so-bad-it’s-good category, and I hereby submit that whoever told Voight that he should make the Bratz movie should be fired immediately.  And then kicked in the nuts.

Tom Hanks’ hair
I submit the following for your consideration: 
In 1993 Tom Hanks shaves his head and wins an Oscar for Philadelphia.
In 1994 Tom Hanks shaves his head and wins an Oscar for Forrest Gump.
In 1998 Tom Hanks shaves his head and is nominated for an Oscar for Saving Private Ryan.
In 2006 people can’t figure out why The Davinci Code failed to rake in buckets of cash and awards.  It was the hair, man!  The hair!  Hanks’ power is inversely proportional to the length of his hair! 

 

Reader Comments

  1. Mack 11/29/2007 @ 11:55am

    Kingsley’s Gandalf the White rip off in The Last Legion is especially spectacular!

  2. Mack 11/29/2007 @ 11:56am

    You also had a lead-in with Cuba Gooding Jr in that previous post. How far up the list was he?

  3. Ardvark 11/29/2007 @ 12:02pm

    When you do the ladies’ version later on, don’t forget Angelina Jolie!
    It always tickles me to see Lara Croft played by a statue-owner…

    But the king of all must be Sir Laurence Olivier, who owned several.
    He was 11 times nominated, 1 actually won as actor, and 2 special honorary Oscars (1947 for his Outstanding achievement as actor, producer and director in bringing Henry V to the screen, and 1979 for the full body of his work, for the unique achievements of his entire career and his lifetime of contribution to the art of film...).
    Yet he won Razzies for “The Jazz Singer” and “Inchon”, and appeared in movies like “Wild Geese 2”.

    When asked why he was in so many bad movies he was known to answer with an honest “For the money!”.

  4. Todd Brown 11/29/2007 @ 3:08pm

    Cua ranks right around Robin Williams for me, not because the bottom end of his work isn’t bad enough but because I don’t think his high end is good enough for there to be an appreciable drop.  I’ve never understood why he won for Jerry McGuire, the only time I’ve ever really liked him is in As Good As It Gets.

  5. andrewz 11/29/2007 @ 3:31pm

    Where’s Halle Berry? I fully expected her in your list.

  6. andrewz 11/29/2007 @ 3:32pm

    D’oh! Ladies another day.

  7. Airchinapilot 02/21/2008 @ 12:03pm

    Voight in Anaconda was awesome: “The jungle ... eet can keel you in a t’ousand waysss.”

Post Your Comments

You must be a registered member to post comments.

If you have a Twitch account, click here to sign in.

If you don't have a Twitch account, click here to register. Don't worry, it's free!

Launch The Twitch Video Player

Stuff We Like

Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.

Our Latest Film & DVD Reviews

More Film & DVD Reviews...

Our Latest Interviews

More Interviews...

Recent Comments