Capote
I have long been of the opinion that the anime label does a grave disservice to a healthy number of Japanese animation directors, visions of poorly drawn pocket monsters keeping wider audiences from discovering a range of dazzling, highly intelligent and challenging worlds. Hayao Miyazaki is obviously one such director. Satoshi Kon is another. Mamoru Oshii very definitely is a third.
An auteur in every sense of the word Oshii’s work, with its fusions of the technological and the philosophical, is instantly distinctive: love him or hate him you simply cannot deny the man’s importance and influence as a film maker. And while he will likely always be known primarily for his work on the ground breaking Ghost in the Shell, start up DVD label Honneamise – distributed here in Canada by Paradox Entertainment - is continuing to lavish attention on Oshii’s Patlabor films, arguably the features where Oshii found his distinctive balance. We heaped praise on Honneamise’s stellar limited edition release of the first Patlabor film not so long back and their new release of the second Patlabor feature is no less impressive. And while the first Patlabor amply demonstrated the lasting value of Oshii’s themes this second feature is positively eerie in its timeliness. Though it is now thirteen years old this is a film that speaks directly to the issues of today.
Set three years following the first film this film once again revolves around Tokyo’s Mobile Police Special Vehicles Unit, the unit assigned to investigate crimes involving Labors, the massive robots originally designed to aid in large scale construction but since adapted to other uses. This crew of cops had been Oshii’s playground for years prior to this film, the director having been involved with several earlier incarnations, and with OVAs, the previous feature, and a television series already wrapped up the thinking was that this film was the time to wrap things up, and so the basic formula has shifted slightly. In Oshii’s own words this film captures his characters on the cusp of change, caught up in larger issues than ever before and therefore forced to grow and adapt. And these changes are immediately obvious to any fan of the series, SV Unit 2 – the core unit of all Patlabor incarnations to this point - having largely scattered to the four winds since the previous film and settled into different jobs, leaving only Commanders Gotoh and Nagumo to hang the story upon.
Where previous Patlabor projects were noted for their character interactions and light tone, this is by far a darker and more serious affair, with a prologue set three years prior to the main body of the film introducing Tsuge, a Labor instructor who shares a history with Nagumo, taking part in a Labor based squad of UN peacekeepers decimated on their assignment when superior officers refuse to give the order for them to engage an obviously hostile enemy. Tsuge survives and returns to Tokyo but promptly disappears upon returning to his native land and is forgotten until what appears to be a Japan Self Defense Force F16 blows up a Tokyo bridge. The city is thrown into chaos, political forces arrayed against each other, as a campaign of terror slowly gains steam with no clear end beyond simply causing chaos. With Tsuge as the prime target and Nagumo’s past ties to him well known, Gotoh and Nagumo’s aid is enlisted to help track down the terrorists.
If ever there was a director capable of tackling issues of terrorism, politics and media manipulation, Oshii is that director. While admiring the passion of his villain and obviously sympathetic to his point of view – Oshii slaps out hard against the hypocrisy and willful ignorance required to maintain the “false peace” that is the status quo – he is nonetheless equally horrified at mankind’s potential for violence. His is a thoughtful look at the causes and results of terrorism, a philosophical treatise on what drives people to such extremes. Though it doesn’t reach the sorts of idea driven extremes Oshii embraced with his Innocence, this is by far a denser and more challenging film than Patlabor 1, a film that tucked its philosophy away under the gloss of high entertainment while this one wears its core issues on its sleeve.
This is not to say that Patlabor 2 is not an entertaining film, however, not by a long shot. The script, though dense, takes time to inject a dose of levity here and there as it unspools. While earlier incarnations tended towards action-comedy, Patlabor 2 is more of a political thriller complete with double agents and hidden agendas. It plays by a different set of rules than did the earlier entries but – as he has shown elsewhere – Oshii is perfectly at home dealing with political intrigue. The film also has the added benefit of digging deeper into the characters of Gotoh and Nagumo, two of the most intriguing characters in this world both of whom reveal much of what had only been hinted at before. And though the animation is clearly a product of its time – dominantly hand drawn and striving for realism – the artwork is uniformly excellent, Oshii here assisted by Satoshi Kon’s work as a key artist.
The limited collector’s set of the film is every bit a match to the excellent release given to the first film. Once again we get a quality remaster of the film, with both audio and video greatly improved from previous editions. English and Japanese soundtracks are both offered in 5.1 surround with flawless English subtitles. The second disc contains a forty plus minute making of documentary. The real plus on the feature front is, once again, the two books that come included in the heavy gauge box set. First you get an entire set of storyboards for the film by Oshii himself, then you get the Patlabor 2 Movie Archives, a 142 page book that collects every possible scrap of information regarding the production of the film. These Honneamise Patlabor box sets are simply stunning releases, absolutely packed with extra information to bolster the excellent transfers given to the films themselves. These come with our very highest recommendation.
Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.
Reader Comments
The Anime Blog 08/07/2006 @ 6:37pm
I agree with you very much - Mamoru Oshii is indeed a visionary director. Between the powerhouse directors Hayao Miyazaki, Satoshi Kon and Katsuhiro Otomo, I think Oshii fits very well with these directors.
Great overview of Patlabor 1 & 2 - especially great is how you mentioned that there certainly is a shift in tone between the two films.
Dhanin 08/07/2006 @ 9:26pm
Patlabor is one of my favorite mecha, instead of Gundam. And you give us a great review about it, good work. Btw, why X’s K-Drama Hub and Chungmuro Daily is not updating daily, it stood at July 31
Noah 08/07/2006 @ 10:11pm
This film is amazing. I always felt alone in this opinion but reading your review Todd gives me some glimmer of hope that a thoughtfully paced film can win over a action paced speed edit. The set designs framed by Satoshi Kon are my favorite part. They really allow for a looseness of thought as the characters ramble and consult each other.I had never had a sense of area from a film as I have from this film. The Mecha cateogory of Anime is such a rich genre and what I love most about them is the character development and worlds that often take dominance over the actual Mecha the series are named after. I hope the original Mobile Suit Gundam Series finally gets the complete boxset treatment it deserves.
Jasper 08/08/2006 @ 3:40am
Gotta agree - Mamoru Oshii is one of the most important figures in the creative industry in Japan today. What I love about this film is, aside from it really representing a moment when Oshii moved into a completely different intellectual leagure to his peers, was how it still managed to use the PATALABOR universive to create something completely different from the first film, which in itself was a great film. Definitely worth checking out.
Ardvark 08/08/2006 @ 5:11am
Excellent review, Todd - one of the first for this release, I might add.
Patlabor 2 always strikes me as vastly underrated in the West. Apparently it is one of Oshii’s own favorites. It baffles me that with both Satoshi Kon and Mamoru Oshii involved this movie doesn’t get more love and attention.
Brilliant release by Honneamise, I especially liked how the booklet explained the similarities (and differences) between the coup détat in the OVA series and this film.
Anyone know what Honneamise’s future plans are? Their website still only shows Patlabor 1.
George 08/08/2006 @ 7:24pm
This release certainly slipped under my radar. There doesnt seem to be any info of it on the official Bandai Visual/Honneamise webpage. I wonder if they are even still planning on releasing the updated version of Wings of Honneamise.
I don’t think these limited editions have been selling well. My local Best Buy has sold only 1 out of the 5 copies they’ve had throughout the months.. it also still seems to be in stock at various online retailers. A shame, since these are great releases for great animations.
-----