Ping Pong
after hearing some good things about this movie i decided to give it a go and for me it definitely didn’t live up to what i read. It was not funny and took itself too serious with the life lessons through ping pong. It was mildly amusing at best. I kept picturing what this movie would be like if they redid it in america (switching the humor for american audiences and switching the sport like street dancing) and all i could think of was a bad teen comedy mixed with You Got Served…. not that it was THAT bad. It had it’s moments, but overall didn’t get the warm fuzzy feelings it was intended to give.
I’m a little surprised to see a comment like this for this film - I’m assuming you viewed the recently released R1 DVD - (as I was also surprised by the lukewarm review at DVDTalk). I picked up the Japanese R2 back in 03 or 04 a year or two after initially reading a rave review of it at kfccinema and loved it.
Of course, when I put it in perspective, I suppose some of these reviews (like the negative ones I’ve seen for Tears of the Black Tiger) - are a little like my initial reaction to viewing “Reservoir Dogs” and “Pulp Fiction” in 2000-2001 (can’t remember when exactly), but well after I viewed “Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels”, “Snatch”, and “Fight Club” - or to be honest, my initial reactions to watching something like “Akira” in college.
I guess some films, as good as they may (or may not) be, are really creatures of their time (and culture). Even a couple years after something’s come out, the genre can already be beaten to death in some cases. And unfortunately, we in the US often get the tail end of popular culture overseas before someone sees fit to release the one film (or films) that started it all. That’s probably my biggest reason for importing. Partly the “I saw it first factor” - which isn’t as big of a deal since I’m no longer hanging around with my college computer store buddies and talking about badass movies every day, but really now just looking for the next interesting thing.
wow, I got heavy on the parentheticals there. I need to practice casual writing more ;p
I’m the same way. I like being “that guy” that all your friends go to for the latest in movies; foreign or otherwise and I too just have that itch to see it as soon as it’s released instead of waiting a year or two. Somehow Ping Pong slipped by me when it was released and I just happened across it on IMDB. I went on to read all the glowing reviews for it and perhaps my expectations went a tad too high (as they tend to do sometimes no matter how hard i try not to let them interfere) and perhaps that is the reason I didn’t enjoy it as much. As I said, it’s not that I felt it to be a bad film… just not a great one. The comedy for me didn’t hold much weight (i’m sure a cultural thing) and the emotional payoff wasn’t there for me either. While it had it’s moments and some scenes were great… overall it was only an alright film for me. Glad I saw it once but probably wouldn’t watch again.
