Last Life In The Universe

Fantasia 09 Review: THIRST

by Todd Brown, July 14, 2009 11:10 PM

[Our thanks to Lauren Baggett for the following review.]

I must confess to being a little confused by some of the reception to THIRST. I rushed home immediately after Sunday's screening, eager to finally read all of the reviews I had been avoiding in order to keep myself unspoiled, only to find that the general opinion has been pretty mixed. Turns out that the very same elements I thought to be assets to the film were seen by others as liabilities. It makes me wonder if Park Chan-wook is becoming a victim of his own success. Just look at the critical reception to I'M A CYBORG BUT THAT'S OK: sure, the film was uneven, but its charm was all but ignored in favor of pronouncements that Park should stick to revenge flicks.

THIRST is not exactly the awaited return to form some fans have been expecting. For one thing, this is not your typical vampire film. Sang-hyun, our tormented vampiric priest, has no fangs. He's stuck using sharp objects, or simply chomping down really hard. Initially he takes pains to do no harm, slurping blood from comatose patients' IV lines. But soon, controlling his appetites proves to be... difficult, to say the least. What sets THIRST apart from its genre predecessors is what happens once Sang-hyun embraces his new state of being. Instead of a bloodbath, the film becomes a very personal drama augmented by bursts of blacker than black humor. For all the sturm und drang, this is a more controlled Park, and that might be where the problem lies for some. For all the sensationalistic coverage of THIRST before anyone actually saw it, it's understandable why the finished product might come across as a bit neutered. Not to say that it isn't violent or sexy. It is. But THIRST is conducted with a smoother and firmer hand, replacing the frenetic, jittery pace of OLDBOY or the baroque unreality of LADY VENGEANCE. It's a bit funny to say that a vampire film has a more realistic tone, but it does. Colors are more muted (though there's still some striking imagery), and dramatic set-pieces are down to a minimum. One sequence that does stand out is Sang-hyun cradling Tae-ju as he leaps from rooftop to rooftop. The camera stays on Tae-ju's face the entire time, jolting slightly whenever Sang-hyun lands on another roof, capturing the sense of new-found freedom the two of them have discovered. It's the only time the two lovers are truly happy, and the scene is brilliant in its simplicity. (Plus, the camera angles obscure some dubious CGI work, an unfortunate low point in the film.)

Song Kang-ho portrays Sang-hyun's torment beautifully, but the film belongs to Kim Ok-vin. At once vulnerable and fiery, she portrays Tae-ju with a sulk and a spine of steel, a spine which shows itself more and more once she becomes entangled with Sang-hyun. Her transformation into a gleefully amoral siren armed with sharp objects turns the final act into a riveting experience.

If the film lags anywhere, it's at the start of the third act, with Tae-ju and Sang-hyun locked in a twisted domesticity that isn't nearly as interesting as it should be. But their fragile situation soon reaches a boiling point, and THIRST quickly careens into a magnificently shot dénouement and a bleak but beautiful ending. To me, THIRST marks a turning point in the work of Park Chan-wook, and I'm really excited to see what he can come up with next if he continues in this vein.

Then again, I'm a big I'M A CYBORG BUT THAT'S OK apologist, so your own mileage may vary.

Review by Lauren Baggett.

More from Thirst:

More from Thirst:

 
 

7 Comments

user-pic

I like I'm a Cyborg too. It's not a perfect film by any means, but it certainly has it's charm. In my eyes it was quite better than Lady Vengeance. Needless to say, I'm Thirsty : )

user-pic

And THIS review has gotten me more stoked to see this film than the trailers did. Damn. Well done!

user-pic

It's very nice to read from people who love I'M A CYBORG, BUT THAT'S OK. I loved the film (well obviously I did since I bought the film for Canada, will come out after Thrist btw), and I never understood why so many would speak their distaste for it.

2 months ago I read an interview with Park Chan-wook where he made a nice metaphor of his films: While the revenge trilogy could be compared to three courses of a meal of substance, I'm a cyborg is the nice sweet that follows, and Thirst is getting the bill at the end.

user-pic

It's really interesting to see all of the informed opinions, both positive and negative, on the film. No matter how people feel about it, they seem to feel it pretty strongly!

Fantasia crowds are notoriously raucous, rpmasse, this is true. Most of the time it's appropriate, but I've certainly been to films over the years where the usual crowd response seemed inappropriate at best (like cheering during rape scenes). The reaction to some of the more upsetting material in STRANGE CIRCUS a few years back was pretty disconcerting.

user-pic

rpmasse. If the only film from Park you like is Oldboy then obviously you DON'T know when a movie is good or not.

Sympathy For Mr. Vengeance & JSA are both incredible films.

user-pic

2bit, I said that even if I didn't like THIRST, it was a good movie. I never really liked RESERVOIR DOG, but its a good movie too. I was talking about tastes and perception. Closed.

user-pic

So, how can you not like a movie but still think it's good? Good in it's technical aspects? Like, that the movie has some good shots, good photography and so on? Yeah sure, you could say that a dish looks great, and has an incredible presentation, but if tastes like shit what's the point?

Anyway, i really don't want to get into a full rant/debate about this, i'll just quote Herzog: "Film is not analysis, it is the agitation of mind; cinema comes from the country fair and the circus, not from art and academicism"

As for Park Chan Wook, his movies always divide opinions, Oldboy got plenty of hate too at it's time. I hated "Cyborg" but that's not enough to dismiss Park. The man is full of ideas, and Thirst certainly looks quite interesting.