Vengeance

DRAGONBALL: EVOLUTION Review

by Peter Martin, April 12, 2009 3:29 AM


Dear Dragonball: Evolution Filmmakers:

Even knowing nothing about the original manga by Akira Toriyama, I feel safe in saying that you, sirs, have not made a movie that deserves the name.

At least, I hope not, because I cannot believe that one of the most popular manga series of all times bears any close resemblance to the movie that you have unleashed upon the world.

You cast Justin Chatwin as Goku, an actor in his mid-20s who is probably a perfectly nice gentlemen in real life, good-looking, easygoing, and prompt for his set calls. He is somewhat believable as a feckless 18 year old, but entirely ineffectual as a warrior in training. His stunt doubles (Jackson Spidell and César René Vigné), however, did some pretty good work, and I must allow that the fight scene in which Goku avoids hitting anyone is nicely choreographed.

But we simply must address the casting of Chow Yun-Fat and, while, we're at it, ask producer Stephen Chow: "What the hell were you thinking?"

I've respected the idea that Chow Yun-Fat has been "selective" in choosing his roles over the past half-dozen years. It's his life, his time, his effort that's required, and he's earned the right to be picky. So what element of this movie made him want to play the part of Master Roshi? Friendship with Stephen Chow? The prospect of filming in Mexico (lovely locations, by the way)? The idea that he could wear a Hawaiian shirt instead of a suit, and not have to fire a gun? The opportunity to work with director James Wong, who previously made the very entertaining Final Destination and Final Destination 3, but also The One with Jet Li? Surely it could not have been the script.

I can certainly understand your possible defense of the film. Perhaps you'll say, "It's for children!" Indeed, several children sitting around me last night found the film entertaining. (Of course, one of them also sang along with the pre-show ads, but no matter.) On that score, the film avoids profanity, shies away from violence beyond TV-style fisticuffs, and sexuality is limited to a chaste kissing at the end. Emmy Rossum is kept under wraps as Bulma, though Jamie Chung is allowed to emphasize her cleavage as Chi Chi. But she's the love interest for Goku, so I guess kids will look away, understanding it's a little bonus for their dads that have brought them to the theater.

Still, even children deserve entertainment that doesn't look so shabby. The opening scene, in which Goku spars with Grandpa Gohan (Randall Duk Kim), had blue screen and wire work that looked so cheap and obvious, I thought it was intended as a parody, that the camera would pull back to reveal the scene to be a dream sequence in which Goku imagines he's in a low-budget kung fu flick from the 70s. But, no, that's the actual level of quality that establishes what is to come.

Back to you, Mr. Chow.

Getting this project underway: not an entirely bad idea. Everything else: a sad, sorry stain upon your resume.

There's no good reason at all that Dragonball: Evolution should have turned out so poorly. Except that, at some point, you all abdicated your responsibility to step back and realize that things were not turning out well. I don't doubt your desire to make a good movie, and I'm sure that the entire crew worked very hard for many long days, weeks, and months. But you lost your objectivity the minute you approved that opening sequence. That should have tipped you off.

Unless, of course, this is exactly the movie you set out to make. In which case, I want my money back.

Sincerely,
Peter.

 
Rate this story:
 
 

13 Comments

user-pic

O.K I can not agree more with every thing you have stated in this review, but i go even further to asking how is it possible for people to keep making bad moves based of animes, mangas, video games, i mean it´s all there the was the characters acts and looks and the action simply needs to been turned from a cartoon to something that looks real and with todays CGI there is no reason for people to make movies that are this bad ever!! Oh yeah i now why because its so increadibly hard to make a 2 hour movie from a million hours of anime that is a gay excuse, i mean what the hell they say we need to tell a story that even people that aren´t fans can enjoy you dummy the reason your making this film is because of its world wide. Well unfortunetly the new generation of film makers are getting worst which is sad with all the money and tecnology that they have available, TO all the people that are making action films this is my humble advice forget about the actors hire someone that can do what is needed if the actor need a stunt double then screw him and hire the stunt double it´s not shakespear, and if you can watch the move with no sound like a silent film and its still good then you did something right.
Thanks Twitchfilm for all the good info and reviews.

user-pic

There are indeed lots of stories, Characters and whatsoever in Anime, Manga, Cartoon, V-Games. But the point is, the filmmakers are not interested in telling these stories, cause they are no fans, they maybe like it, but they don't love it. All they need is the name of the Anime or V-Game hoping it will bring cash.
I hope dragonball:evolution will make no money, one has to learn his lesson.

They really should let tell these stories by people like Christoph Gans. His Crying Freeman was awesome.

user-pic

"Indeed, several children sitting around me last night found the film entertaining. (Of course, one of them also sang along with the pre-show ads, but no matter.)"

Loved that part.

user-pic

Heh nice review, still I cant resist seeing this crap. @Cuttermaran. AMen, Crying Freeman is still awesome.

user-pic

Considering the lack of promotion of the film in the USA, it's safe to say that the studio is waiting to get the money from the international box office. They are confident that they will drag enough clueless fans to see this. Which by the way, anyone knows how this did in Asia? Box office-wise that is, i can't think of anyone over 12 that could like this film.

user-pic

Unbelievably this actually gets a release over here in the Netherlands.
Instead of, like, any other movie I'd really like to see...

user-pic

(Which by the way, anyone knows how this did in Asia?)

25 million and growing. Nearly 8 million in China and 8 1/2 in Japan. Here's the breakdown around the rest of the world...
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?page=intl&id=dragonball.htm

user-pic

So, is this looking to be a flop ?
Domestic-wise, it seems headed towards that direction.

user-pic

Yeah, Dragonball: Evolution bombed with grossing only $4.6 million over the Easter weekend. With a film budget at 45-50 million, this is consider a substantial loss. I guess a sequel getting the greenlit is out of the question. The folks at Fox studios are on a bad streak as of late, aside from Taken.

user-pic

Yeah, just judging from personal experience, it seemed the Japanese were incredibly psyched about the film. The marketing gurus had done a good job plastering posters all over Tokyo, and despite Yatterman having just been released, all the talk was about Dragonball. It was pretty sad, actually.

user-pic

This movie was pure shit. Me and a friend watched it to mock it, and it even exceeded our already rock bottom expectations. This is easily one of the worst movies I have ever seen!

user-pic

So is this movie and the chun li movie that came out earlier this year tied for the best movie ever made??

user-pic

I tried so hard to lower my expectations because I knew it was going to be bad. It had some decent parts, and I did love Justin Chatwin as the awkward teen, but I completely agree that he was not that great for the fight scenes. The final signature Goku attack felt like it had no feeling. I did have a fun time in the theater though, so I suppose it wasn't a total loss.

On the other hand, there were about ten people in the theater and it was the second night it had been out.