
Forget everything you know about Feng Xiaogang. While Zhang Yimou, one of China's most revered arthouse directors, used the wuxia epic to make a move towards mainstream success director Feng, one of China's most successful commercial directors, is here using the wuxia to make exactly the opposite move. Feng's adaptation of Shakespeare's Hamlet, The Banquet -- available on DVD here -- is every inch an epic scaled art film -- deeply theatrical, stunningly beautiful, filled with intriguing contradictions, and a surprisingly faithful adaptation of the source material.
Set in tenth century China when the vast land was a political shambles, the dominant empire crumbling with rebellious regions splintering off into rival kingdoms, The Banquet stars Daniel Wu -- a major star who has long since outgrown the teen idol roles that inexplicably remain his staple -- as Wu Luan, the reluctant crown prince of the empire who withdrew to the country and joined an acting troupe three years previous when his father married Wan (Zhang Ziyi), his childhood friend and would-be lover. Wu Luan's quiet life as an artist is shattered when his ambitious uncle kills the Emperor, assumes the throne and sends a band of assassins to kill the rightful heir. Wan, for her part, recognizes that the self appointed Emperor is a threat both to herself and to her true love, Wu Luan, and in a bid to protect him agrees to marry the new Emperor. With this slight modification to the character of the queen, who is now step-mother and lover, the film now moves ahead mirroring Hamlet quite closely throughout.
The Banquet is a curious blend of competing and seemingly self-contradictory elements -- at once larger than life yet tightly restrained, both shockingly beautiful and shockingly brutal -- and that Feng is able to pull it off is a testament to his very talented cast, his range of gifted collaborators, and his own skills as a director. Reportedly frustrated with his reputation as a purveyor of fluff Feng has intended The Banquet as proof that he is capable of more and prove his point he has.
What immediately strikes you with The Banquet is the sheer scale of the film. Feng has a gifted and experienced design crew -- many of whom won Oscars for their work on Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon -- and he has clearly also been granted a budget to let them indulge themselves fully. The sets, the armour, the costuming, it is all intricately detailed and truly epic. The opening theater set is simply gorgeous while the Imperial Castle truly deserves the 'epic' tag and must surely be one of the largest standing sets ever constructed. But what sets Feng's environments apart from most is that while creating things on a truly massive scale he also shows a dedication to realism, stone walls weathered and undressed, floors largely made of polished wood, everything obviously well used. While Zhang has filled his wuxia epics with environments that dazzle with the heightened use of color Feng has opted to create something that is simultaneously epic and yet entirely plausible.
Given the structure of the film it also will not take long to be greatly impressed by the martial arts choreography. Though the film is actually significantly more focused on drama and palace intrigue than it is with hand to hand combat it opens with a simply stunning sequence and all subsequent sequences show every bit as much verve. Just when you though you had seen everything that veteran choreographer Yuen Wo-Ping had to offer on the fight along comes something like this film, in which Yuen shows us something entirely new. His fusion of grace and brutality suggests that Yuen may have spent some time with The Duelist recently but he has taken those influences and made them into something else entirely, crafting martial arts sequences that are graceful and flowing while also acknowledging the raw brutality of hand to hand combat. It is also quite refreshing to see Wu, a legitimate martial artist, given a rare chance to show his physical skills on screen.
Dazzling production values aside, The Banquet would come to naught if not paired with a cast capable of filling those environments, and Feng's cast does exactly that. Zhang Ziyi turns in another in her line of strong performances, Wu shows more than he has been given opportunity to since One Night In Mongkok and the rest of the cast is similarly experienced and talented. The script is remarkably sparse and restrained, rarely wasting words and trusting the actors to carry the emotion of the piece through actions rather than dialogue. They do exactly that.
Ironically it is the strengths of The Banquet that will likely also limit its success. People go to a film made at this scale expecting a similarly flashy story line, equivalent bursts of action and sheer entertainment, but at its heart The Banquet is essentially a chamber drama, a film purely and totally concerned with the consequences of unbridled desire. Feng's success in showing himself capable of 'serious' film, captured as it is in the trappings of epic entertainment, will itself make it difficult for the film to find a widespread audience.
One surprising -- and major -- oversight aside the new Hong Kong DVD release is simply stellar. The film is presented in its proper 2.35:1 screen ratio with an anamorphic transfer optimized for 16x9 screens. The transfer is crystal clear with deep, rich colors and excellent contrasts, see the screen captures below for examples. Sound comes in 5.1 and DTS options and the optional English subtitles are clearly translated and easy to read. The bonus disc is loaded to the gills as well, featuring a fifteen minute making of, interviews with cast and crew -- Zhang Ziyi, Daniel Wu, Zhou Xun, Ge You, Yuen Wo-Ping and Feng Xiaogang -- a pair of behind the scenes features -- one clocking in at 16 minutes, the other at 40 -- and a complete range of promotional materials. Alas, this is the disc where the shocking omission occurs. How is it that a release as clearly targetted at the export market as this one is -- hence the release being coded region free -- could omit English subtitles on the special features? Quite surprising considering both the international recognition the film has received and the current state of Hong Kong DVD releases, in which subtitled feature sets are rapidly becoming the norm. This edition also comes with a beautiful photo book, the first half of which doubles as a calendar.
Screen Capture One
Screen Capture Two
Screen Capture Three
Screen Capture Four
Screen Capture Five
More from Banquet, The:
- Reviews: The Banquet Review
- Reviews: The Banquet Review
- Reviews: TIFF Report: The Banquet

Can't wait, pure and simple. Though I'll have to.
Though... Xiaogang has a reputation as a director of fluff? I was unaware of this -- Big Shot's Funeral is a satire on rampant commercialism IIRC and from what I've heard of his mainland productions before that apart from his first they're not without meaning and subtext. Even Cellphone's got some level of social commentary, hasn't it? Still, the only one I've actually seen is still A World Without Thieves, which admittedly is slick but empty stuff. Anyway, I knew he was thought of as mainstream, just not as vacant. Oh well. Here's hoping I share your enthusiasm, Todd. :D
Nite.. one Nite in mongkok, if I remember correctly.
Funny though, this is the first positive review of the movie that I have heard of. News has been that it is laughable, but it may be exactly what you said: the audience didn't know what to expect
Not all of Dedadwood is in iambic, but a surprising amount of it is, yeah, and it's increasing season by season. It's amazing how natural they make it sound ...
And yeah, soundtrack's great. Tan Dun's always good ...
Thanks for the review Todd!
Nice review. Zhang Ziyi looks hot in the trailer!
i attended the Gala Presentation of The Banquet at the 31st Toronto International Film Festival. although i was unable to welcome Ziyi along the red carpet i was seated in the second row, main floor of Roy Thomson Hall. from there, i was able snap two photos and shoot video footage of Ms. Zhang's greeting to the audience. here's a photo i took a brief moment after Zhang and Feng walked on stage: http://www.hinjang.com/media/2006_09150009-Zhang_Ziyi-and-Feng_Xiaogang.jpg i reduced the quality of the photo to 1200 x 900 at 28.346 pixels / centimetre. i can personally attest that past reviews of The Banquet -- the good and not-so good -- are accurate.
Spoiler warning:
Who killed Queen Wan??? The Emperor?
Jeff you tosser, at least leave a screens length spoiler before writing the spoiler, tool!
Well, there you go then, the opinions differ about The Banquet, as they indeed should. My point, though, is that it is quite useless and possibly rather insulting to a lot of people to make statements about "real" Chinese films, because there aren't any. The Banquet and Crazy Stone might not have much in common, but they are both definitely Chinese films. Whether they are any good or not is another question entirely.
No, I have to disagree. First off, it's not insulting at all. Second, you don't speak for a lot of people. You speak for yourself. Finally, one can easily argue that a specific film or group of films better represent a particular culture. It's called a national cinema approach and is related to cultural studies. The idea is that to fully understand a film, you must place it in the political and aesthetic climate that produced it. To quote Timothy Corrigan from A Short Guide to Writing About Film, "An Ameican spectator might have little trouble comprehending a Kurosawa film, but without guidance and some cultural background on Japanese society, the films of Kenji Mizoguchi or Mikio Naruse might seem too foreign and confusing for the average American student." As you yourself have alluded too, Crazy Stone would most likely be difficult for many non-Chinese to understand because of its cultural aspects such as language and dialect. I argue that there is little cultural depth to be found in The Banquet beyond what you physicall see/hear on the screen. In other words, aside from the actors, costumes, sets, language, etc, there are very few ties to Chinese culture. On the other hand, I could easily make a case for Crazy Stone as a representative Chinese text because of its cultural depth.
Well, there you go then, opinions differ about The Banquet, as they indeed should. That's not in dispute. My point, though, is that it is quite useful and never insulting to anyone to argue for such things as culturally representative films, because there are many. The Banquet and Crazy Stone might not have much in common, and they are both definitely Chinese films, but one could argue that one film is more "Chinese" and culturally significant than the other using certain approaches. Take films from the Hong Kong New Wave in the 1980s and early 1990s for example. At a time when Hong Kong was trying coming to terms with its multiculturalism and sense of identity, many filmmakers such as Tsui Hark and Ann Hui started making films using local dialects and focusing on local issues. Film is very subjective, but that doesn't mean we can't make a case for our opinions based on cultural research. Stop being so close-minded.
I'm Chinese and I enjoy and welcome good films with ancient China as a background. Shaw Brothers produced a number of historical epics (Empress Wu, Yang Guifei,Diao Chan, Beyond the Great Wall, Kingdom and the Beauty) during the 60's and I hope to see a continuation of this genre from China.
Crazy Stone bored me to death. in comparison with The Banquet, Feng Xiaogang is less showy than Ning Hao. sorry, but i think Crazy Stone is an advertisement for Ning Hao. i really cannot understand how you can claim that it was the other way around.
i loved The Banquet, but unfortunately i had to endure two girls next to me who were giggling throughout the movie.
the final shot is oh-so-gorgeous!
This movie has crazy-beautiful set design, costumes and cinematography. Shame I didn't care for half of the leads, while the other half are very good.
Once again, i was happy to sleep through most of it. I doubt Zhang Ziyi is really the actress that appears naked swimming and all.
-----