
[Originally intending to catch a 35mm print of Andrei Tarkovsky's Sci-Fi masterpiece Stalker, a delay of the print allowed me to head across the way and catch the Gangster Comedy/Drama from Rules of Dating director Han Jae-Rim]
Glossy gangster films are a staple of the Soth Korean film industry. Whether it is the noir stylings of A Bittersweet Life or full blown comedy of the My Wife is a Gangster films, audiences definitely have a taste for the perceived glamour of the lifestyle thrown up on screen time after time. So along comes director Han Jae-Rim and Korean superstar Song Kang-Ho to let the air out of the balloon and subvert the entire sub-genre. I wish I could say that they were 100% successful in their effort. The Show Must Go On is a frustrating affair filled with moments of greatness. The end of the film, when we finally make it there after several false-endings, is a piece of perfection that is not entirely earned by the journey which works in fits and starts (and a healthy suspension of disbelieve in the screenplays many contrivances). The film is hindered by underwritten supporting characters and questionable pacing but glued together with a real magic from Song Kang-Ho who is on screen 98% of the time and is simply a joy to watch.
The film opens with In-Gu commuting to work and falling a sleep at a red light while the traffic honks and tries squeeze around his stationary vehicle. Arriving to his place of business, a produce front, a tad late, he has to take over for his underlings who have nearly botched the coercion of a building contractor to sign over a large construction deal to their gang. Middle aged, slowing down and just plain overwhelmed, In-Gu is hoping this 'big deal' will be his ticket out of gangs and provide the capital to move out to a well-to-do suburb so he can put his family life back together and live happily ever after in domestic bliss. His wife is currently sick of his gangster life, even though she has lived of it for years, and has him sleeping on the couch until he quits the lifestyle. His youngest daughter is rebelling in full force and raises the "I Hate You" to 11 when In-Gu tries to bribe her schoolteacher to give her special treatment. His son is studying (expensively) abroad in Canada. His Brother, also a midlevel gangster, works for a rival gang with direct conflicts of interest. And, finally, while he has the respect of his boss (he is treated like a son in fact) this creates serious complications with the Boss's ambitious young brother who gets less respect and authority. Freshly diagnosed with Type-2 diabetes, middle aged, more than a little lumpy and just plain slowing down, In-Gu turns the effort of balancing all these spinning plates into a sort of comic futility.
The pathos in film is generated by In-Gu's nostalgia for a time when he was young (and things were much simpler) whist trying to please everyone and doing all the dirty work. The film could have easily been called The Good Lieutenant as Song Kang-Ho is the mirror opposite of Harvey Keitel from Abel Ferrara's film (where the circumstances were built by selfish forces rather than selfless ones). Replace the catholic guilt with salary-man domestic expectations and you have a feel for where the film is going in the final chapter where the comedy is discarded and the screws are tightened quite mercilessly.
Large comic set-pieces (In-Gu's lack of business acumen in the construction business results in a burly brawl between gangsters and subcontractors) switch tone on a hearbeat to desperately realistic knife fights photographed in the colourful way that should be familiar to anyone who watches South Korean film. Equally numbered trips to the hospital (for sustained injuries) and the Realtor (to sustain his desire for family life to magically make sense) set the narrative rhythm. That rhythm is often disturbed by underperformed supporting roles which come off as types, not people. This is probably a script problem as much as an acting one. I understand the desire for the filmmakers to keep the focus of Song Kang-Ho's emotionally-chameleon central performance but short-changing his boss, wife, daughter and rival with little to do but just move along the subplots sully the affair somewhat. However, In-Gu's brother is wonderfully realized with just a small amount of screen time. The two of them verbally sparring while reminiscing about the old days ends in a childish water bottle fight that sums up In-Gu's yearnings in one beautifully crafted scene.
It is worth staying for the final moments of the film (despite two or more awkward false endings) which will make the picture a memorable one. The package may be a bit too shiny and events resolve a bit too facilely to earn its punch, but the central performance does wonders. To these western eyes, The Show Must Go On is also an interesting comment on the pressures of middle aged men in modern South Korea and the sacrifices that have to be made along the way. It is a solid attempt to take something decidedly mainstream and stretch its audience.

Kurt, thanks for your discerning comments with regard to the pros and cons of director Han Jae-Rim's THE SHOW MUST GO ON. As I mentioned in an earlier posting on Twitch, I have been anxiously awaiting this Sang Kang-Ho film subsequent to its pre-order on DVD. July 30th can't come soon enough!!
Nice review, Kurt. I'll hold for the time being and wrestle my budget down for something else.
Interesting review, but I disagree with you a little bit. I saw this film at the NYAFF and thought it was near-great. The steady, inexorable descent that the main character tumbles down over the course of the film was anything but contrived, I think, and I must disagree about the supporting characters as well. I think they were drawn quite well, and the acting was uniformly good across the board. From a storytelling standpoint, I think just enough attention was paid to them in order for them to flesh out the main character's story, while still letting him be the main character in the film's tightly focused narrative, with minimal pointless textural distractions. I do, however, agree with you about the ending -- there are definitely too many false endings, but the actual one, when it comes, is definitely worth the wait. I just wish Han Jae-Rim had found a more economical way to deal with his 3rd act. As it stands, that is the film's biggest flaw, but I'd still give the picture a hearty reccomendation to anyone interested, as I found the film to be wonderfully complex, socially conscious, yet endlessly entertaining for both it's humor and brutality -- comparisons to "The Sopranos" are well deserved.
That's too bad about not catching Stalker. I saw the new print at the local cinematheque a few months ago and it is absolutely beautiful.
-----