
Zhang Yimou knew my dead father.
He knew how he felt about his approaching death, his regrets about certain wrong turns in his life, his sins of omission toward his children. And his heartfelt yearning to connect again with a son he had lost.
Those thoughts and emotions tumble together in Zhang's Riding Alone for Thousands of Miles, with familial roles turned inside out. Tanaka (Ken Takakura) is in the twilight of his life, but it is the serious medical condition of his estranged son Ken-ichi (Kichi Nakai) that hastens his desire to reconcile.
Ken-ichi refuses to see the old man, and only the tearful entreaties of daughter-in-law Rie (Shinobu Terajima, a shimmering, solitary performance from the actress who made her mark in Vibrator and It's Only Talk) give Tanaka hope. He sets off on a long trip, with the idea of bringing back something that will soften Ken-ichi.
The temptation is to say that Zhang Yimou returns to doing what he does best in Riding Alone, which has been available on DVD for some time and will open September 1 in the US with limited theatrical engagements. Certainly he is painting on a smaller canvas than his previous two pictures, and the resultant film is a pleasant, modest, artfully-drawn drama, an exquisite portrait of the relationship between a father and son.
Tanaka did something in the past that alienated his son, to the point where they have not spoken in a decade. Tanaka has retreated to a rural island in his native Japan and become a fisherman. When he receives word from Rie that Ken-ichi is very ill, Tanaka quickly boards a train to Tokyo. He is rejected just as quickly by his son, though he stands but a few feet outside his hospital room.
As so often happens with such intergenerational rifts, wife and daughter-in-law Rie is stuck in the middle. She wants to help, and gives Tanaka a videotape she thinks will help him get to know Ken-ichi better. Tanaka seizes on something in the tape and immediately books a trip to China.
The trip, filled with linguistic misunderstandings, bureacratic red tape, and emotional detours, serves as a means for Zhang Yimou and co-writer Zou Jingzhi, along with actor Ken Takakura, to explore Tanaka's psyche. Zhang has stated that he wrote the script with Takakura in mind, but even if the script is simply an expression of Zhang's desire to work with an actor he admired, it's filled with details that will be familiar to any veteran of the war between sire and offspring, a battle that I recognized instantly, and which feels intensely personal.
The multi-award winning Japanese star, perhaps best known to audiences outside Asia for his roles in the Hollywood films The Yakuza, Black Rain, and Mr. Baseball, has more often played action roles, but he is well-suited to the "strong and silent" father figure he embodies here. Tanaka has no idea how to reach his son, lacking any real insight into what makes him tick. He relentlessly pursues an idea that he hopes will bear fruit, with little real expectation that it will happen.
Zhang endeavors to maintain a reserved distance from a story that is inherently melodramatic, in both the framing and the absence of an obtrusive musical score. Still, it's impossible not to feel the "warm fuzzies" when a rebellious young child enters the scene—he's too obviously a substitute player, and even the superemely dramatic backdrop of the spectacular mountainscapes of the rural Yunan Province in China cannot entirely disguise the sentimental ploy.
Even so, Riding Alone rings true, in the same way that Not One Less or Raise the Red Lantern or House of Flying Daggers have depicted their respective landscapes: perhaps not with undebatable honesty, but more with authorial integrity. In other words, you may not buy everything that Zhang Yimou offers, but you believe he is an honest salesman, that he believes what he is saying.
You can't ask much more than that from a man on speaking terms with your dead father.

I'll back off a bit in charging Yimou with a lack of integrity (hard to tell in a country with such strict censorship and a ruler who, just a few months ago, warned filmmakers to comply with party policies or else...), but the effectiveness of the film was lessened for me by those few instances which didn't ring true... And while not every film has to be analysed in terms of political 'accuracy' (whatever that is!), I think it is a fair enough topic for discussion, considering the amount of bureaucratic hurdles Tanaka has to overcome.
it's supposed to be spelled "QIAN", not "QUAN".
Thank you for the correction, "anon." I have updated the review.
since takakura traveled to a remote village, as a viewer i had no compelling reason to believe zhang yimou needed to take his or anyone's beef—reasonable enough as jon pais raised it—to equate the central body of chinese censors with local insitutitions. RIDING ALONE shows subsidiaries, especially peripheral ones, indulge more in personalities of its locals than a faithful, carbon copy of the official stance and line. maybe the political critique you're looking for is in another film, while for takakura's sentimental journey, it's already packing to the eyeballs with death, immense regret, guilt, and desperate redemption.
I enjoyed the film on its own merits and folded a link to your review, Peter, in my own on The Evening Class.
I didn't see the prison warden as "overaccomodating" as much as transparently manipulative about how he wanted the prison to be represented in Tanaka's videotape. I got the sense these prisoners were kept on a tight leash but that the warden was hoping to sugarcoat that fact with a lenient exception.
As for the "excessive generosity" of the Stone Village, again I wasn't as concerned about whether it was true or not as much as understanding it as a narrative device to counterpoint Tanaka's own difficulty in demonstrating generosity. Further, I do think there was a guised comment about how unfair it was of them to not consider Yang Yang's feelings regarding whether or not he wanted to meet his father. There was a sense of their focusing too much on the wrong things. Whether it rang true or not, the scene of the banquet table extending up the street for blocks had a kind of beauty to it, and the scene on the tiled rooftops was clever comic relief.
Within the context of my own interpretation of the film, it might be suggested that much of what Yimou portrays in the film guises things he's *really* portraying.
What really stunned me was how Yang Yang was chosen from 70,000 child applicants!! How in the world was that administered? Man!!
-----