
When word began to circulate about mainland Chinese drama Jasmine Women back in 2003 and 2004 it seemed the sort of film guaranteed to make waves internationally. It is, after all, based on a well regarded novel and features an all star cast built around Zhang Ziyi and Joan Chen. But, for whatever reason, the film simply slipped off the radar and has been seldom seen until now with a new Chinese DVD release making the film widely available.
Told in three segments spanning three distinct time periods Jasmine Women casts both Zhang and Chen in multiple roles as it tells the stories of three generations of of an all female family and their very poor choices in men. The first segment casts Zhang as A Mo – the only character who recurs through all three segements – with Chen as A’s mother, while Chen taking over the A Mo role in both the second and third segments with Zhang playing A’s daughter and grand daughter, respectively.
The film opens in the early thirties, the jazz era in full swing. A Mo is a bright eyed young girl, working with her mother in their family photography shop while obsessing over the movies. When she catches the eye of a lecherous film producer A Mo moves away from home to become an actress against her mother’s wishes and seems well on the road to success when the Cultural Revolution strikes, effectively destroying the film industry and leaving A Mo abandoned, unemployed, pregnant and with no choice but to move back home with her disapproving mother.
The second segment jumps forward slightly more than twenty years to the early fifties. A Mo – now played by Chen – still lives in the apartment over the photography shop, now with her daughter Lily (Zhang). Chinese communism is in full swing and the young Lily has fallen in love with a university classmate, a working class communist party member, who shares a mutual dislike with A Mo. Following a fight with her mother, and with a wildly over-romanticized view of the working class life, Lily leaves home and marries her young love against her mother’s wishes only to receive a rude awakening on lower class life.
We then jump forward in time again to the seventies with Lily’s daughter returning home from an extended time away living in the countryside, during which time she was secretly married to a man about to head to a far away university.
The strength of Jasmine Women is very obviously the attention to period detail and the recreation of these distinct times. The opening segment, in particular, is gorgeously detailed and beautifully shot, many sequences very strongly reminiscent of the old MGM musicals. This was a vibrant time period lovingly recreated and there are much worse things in the world than looking at Zhang done up in period glam. And while the later two pieces may not be as flashy as the opening salvo they are also recreated with a remarkable attention to detail.
Unfortunately the film’s weaknesses are also immediately evident. As you may gather from the above synopses the storylines in all three segments are highly repetitive, the film essentially repeating variations on the same scenario in three different time periods. The characters never seem to progress and little effort being made to differentiate the different characters either of the main actresses play. Perhaps lying at the root of this problem is how the film feels less like a coherent narrative – an actual story about actual people – than it does a type of historical tourism, a series of events strung together more to guide you through an era than to introduce you to any particular character. Coming in at forty to forty five minutes each the individual segments aren’t long enough for any sort of extended character development but are long enough to bloat the total running time to two hours and ten minutes, which is far too long for a film that repeats itself as often as this one does.
The mainland Chinese DVD release is pretty much what you would expect from the Zoke Culture DVD label, which is to say not particularly good. Presented in a letterboxed widescreen format the transfer is soft and noticeably grainy with high contrast elements tending to bleed out somewhat. And while the subtitles give enough to follow the story with little effort they are definitely of the “Engrish” variety – poorly translated and littered with grammar and syntax errors.

Hey Jasper ... I could've sworn I saw some large banners of Chairman Mao flying in the background during the military sequence, which is why I assumed that was the cultural revolution. Since it never gives any clear date for events I was mostly guessing on the time periods. I guess I got close but not close enough.
As to the repetition, I totally got the point of it I just thought it made for rather dry viewing and I really questioned why Joan Chen, in particular, played her two different characters exactly the same way. That struck a bad note with me. It seemed the sort of device that works well in print but doesn't really translate on film.
Hi Todd, well I couldnt say 100% it was the Japanese invasion or the Cultural revolution, as it was a few years ago when I saw it, so you may be right. I'll have to take a look again.
I guess regarding its dramatic structure, well, you either like it or you don't. I think it worked for me because i saw it on a big screen, and it was during a festival chockfull of incredibly weak films, so this was one of the standouts. I've spoken to some people about the film and I admit no one has been quite as enthusiastic as me. But it brought a tear to my jaded eye, so I'll be sure to be revisiting this one soon.
i just watched the film today. i thought it was quite well done. the acting was good. it wasn't the cultural revolution but the Japanese invasion.one thing that i liked abt the film was that it showed another side of Chinese women, not the usual stereotype. i do need to read the novel though.
kim
Yeah, I would say I agree with the comment on this movie being repetitive and not really accomplishing anything in doing so. It reminded me of watching Joy Luck Club in the women making bad choices in men, and it transcends generations. But with Joy Luck Club even though it was the same theme repeating itself over and over, there was more indepth charater development which made you care about what happens, or made things unpredicable. Jasmine Women was completely predictable becuase after the first segment was over, and you realize the 2nd and 3rd were just the same, there's no intrige anymore.
I have to say however, this movie was pretty well made. The look of the movie was impressive, esp. the first segment, shanghai 1930's. and overall, just a lot of attention to the period it was in, and the set design, the art, the cinematography, etc. I'd watch this movie again, just for that. I only wish the plot and characters were more interesting or had more variation.
I just don't have anything to say. Not that it matters. Eh. I've just been staying at home doing nothing, but I don't care. That's how it is.
Trivia: Chinese title is Mo Li Hua (= Jasmine Flower). As is quite common for chinese female names to adopt those for flowers. So the three characters in the film also make up the title (i.e. Mo, Li and Hua).
I can't be bothered with anything these days, but such is life. I don't care. So it goes. More or less nothing seems worth thinking about. I've just been hanging out waiting for something to happen, but that's how it is.
My life's been pretty dull recently. Shrug. My mind is like a void. I haven't gotten anything done lately. I can't be bothered with anything recently.
I love this movie, very beautiful cinematography, very nice & careful portray of different eras. I also loves the mellifluous voices of the different girls who sing "Mo Li Hua". Additionally, different songs at the background enhance the viewer's experience of journey through time, from the jazz music bacground of Mo's era, the PRC party's songs of Li's era, to Teresa Deng's famous songs of Hua's era.
-----