Everybody say it together now: misleading trailers hurt films. While it is certainly an understandable urge to seize on the most easily marketable aspect of a production to stir interest in the public it’s a dangerous thing to do. Bring an audience in expecting something and you’d better deliver it, and do so promptly, or you risk having them turn on you for not giving them what they expect regardless of whether what you give them is good or not. Such is the case with Russia’s Paragraph 78, a film presented in its trailers as a straight ahead action picture with some sci-fi and possible even horror edges the film is far, far more a character drama with the action not kicking in on any significant scale until the final third. This is a problem for an audience brought in expecting high octane.
The Russian military has a problem. A secret research laboratory working illegally creating viruses for use in war has gone silent. Normal communications have ended abruptly with the only sound emerging coming in the form of an emergency beacon on a public channel – a major problem since it could draw international attention to a lab which is not supposed to exist. Clearly something has gone wrong and what, exactly, that is needs to be discovered and contained as quickly as possible but regular troops can’t be used since that would leave behind a potentially incriminating paper trail. The solution? An off the books, specialized unit disbanded years before is reassembled and sent in. They don’t exist in any of the records and so are perfect for the military’s purposes. What does not officially exist cannot incriminate and they are also, ultimately, fully expendable should the situation fall into the worst case scenario. It does, of course. The experimental virus has mutated and escaped, killing off the research crew. There is no known antidote and the team sent in to mop up the mess are themselves infected leaving them only hours to live.
So. What Paragraph 78 is not is any sort of conventional action film. The only enemy here is the virus itself, an invisible killer. What the film actually is is a character study of the relationship and tensions within the group and how those escalate once the pressure is on – escalating to the point where the decide that since they are about to die anyway they may as well hasten the process by hunting each other down in a sort of tournament. The futuristic element never comes into play, we never see the effects of the virus in the soldiers, the is purely about the human response to extreme pressure.
On a technical level the film – like everything to come out of producer Joseph Bakshiev’s MB Productions thus far – is fantastic. It is exceptionally well shot and constructed, with a very solid cast. When the action sequences do kick in they are inventive and engaging, with one sequence in particular coming across as a crunchier version of the gun-kata employed by Christian Bale in Equilibrium. Perhaps even more importantly the action sequences do an admirable job of exposing the different characters’ personalities.
The question, though, is whether people will have the patience to get to those action sequences. Released in Russia as two feature length films – the first focused on the set up and initial character work, the second on the more action oriented material – it has been cut down into a single two hour and ten minute feature for international audiences. Even with the reductions the film probably needs to get to the infection fifteen minutes or so earlier than it does as it currently stands. Good casting or no the early going is very much dialogue driven, filled with bluster as the soldiers trade jokes and barbs with one another and the rhythm of this sort of verbal back and forth never translates particularly well into subtitles, which is definitely the case here. Verbal sparring is about personality rather than literal content and content is all that the translation really gives you. Throw in some specifically Russian jokes and cultural references and you have a film that will be difficult going for a casual western audience looking for an action fix.
That's unfortunate seen as the trailer for this had it all looking like a very well polished actioner. Still interested I suppose..
I agree, Paragraph 78 is not the best film. But however, the atmosphere is good, and action scenes are good too.
Still, the trend of developing of Russian film industry is very-very optimistic. It was impossible 3-4 years ago to even imagine, that film of that quality will ever appear in Russia. Film industry was totally dead 4 years ago, and now it is on rise. That's great!
P.S.: i'm personally waiting for action movie Smersh 21, it is in production now.
I agree 100% Vladimir. Russia is one of the most exciting film countries in the world right now and definitely worth watching. And I really think P78's production co is one of the key companies to be watching. I've not heard of Smersh 21, could you send some details?
Todd, it is in production now. I've seen only few photos and report on TV.
The site is: http://www.smersh-xxi.ru/
but it is under construction now.
The page on russian movie db: http://kinoros.ru/db/movies/771/index.html
It is based on the fantastic novel of V. Golovachev and the production of the film began about 2 weeks ago.
P.S.: also i'm waiting for "Inhabited Island" - fantasy film based on the novel of Strugatsky brothers, and directed by Bondarchuk. It is #1 in my personal rating.
Will we be seeing a subtitled release of the Russian cut of Paragraph 78? Or will we have to wait for a butchered version with nearly half of the films missing?
I also agree Russia is producing some of the most exciting cinema in the world, I just wish some US companies would take a punt on their films! ( i.e BIMMER 2! ) How can one of Russia's highest grossing films ever not catch the eye of any companies? :(
Judging by that screenshot the US will remake this starring George Clooney.
Well bellamy i don't think u should be eager to watch the Russian uncut version because the only reason they splitted the finished movie into exaggerated 2 episodes is to earn more money and try to cover expenses on production which became much more expensive then was anticipated. In fact it's the director's cut, i believe, which is released internationally, because it was 2:10 as Hleborodov wrote in his blog. Two episodes are far more boring and make little sense apart from each other. Well the second one, when the action starts, is not bad.
I'm glad that a cinematography and fights of this level are released by Russian filmmakers, that makes me anticipate a bright future for Russian cinema... but the acting was horrible. Not because of the actors (some of which are very good, as can be seen in other films), but because of directing, I suppose then. And funnily enough, it was completely americanized, even the jokes! The dialogues sound as if they were poorly translated from American English.
So for me, the only worth of P78 is the gun-kata and the production level. Which is not bad at this stage anyway.
Shop at our affiliated sites and support Twitch while feeding your pop-culture addiction.
|